05. Conclusion

Jane Austen, Elizabeth Gaskell and Charlotte Brontë show in their novels different places, societies and classes. But they all reflect women inferiority and their financially dependance on men. Marriage is still important in North and South and Jane Eyre, but is not one of the main topics, as in Pride and Prejudice.

Jane Austen, definitely, idealises Pride and Prejudice’s society, but Elizabeth Bennet is a timeless character that is still admired by women today. This is probably the reason why Austen is considered a forward-thinking woman. Besides, she created Elizabeth Bennet when revolutionary ideas had not arrived to Austen’s society, whereas they where known by Gaskell and Brontë. She may be quite conservative, but she developed a character modern, clever and rebellious character before women became concious of their situation and started fighting for change it. So, it is true Austen was formard-thinking, but she was also brilliant and created characters surprisingly realistic and understood and reflected perfectly women’s psychology.

 

Add comment mayo 21st, 2013

03. Love and Marriage in Pride and Prejudice, North and South and Jane Eyre

Love and Marriage have an important role in these three novels.

“Charlotte Brontë thought to herself as the antithesis of Jane Austen- passionate where Austen was restrained and decorous, plebeian where Austen was a ladylike- and some ways this is true.” (Patrick Parrinder, Nation and Novel: The English Novel from its Origins to the Present Day). But, despite Austen and Brontë’s differences, the love stories actually follow a similar structure.

Especially in Pride and Prejudice and North and South. In Laurel Ann Nattress’ blog we can read: « Often compared to Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, Gaskell’s North and South parallels many of the same misunderstanding and misconceptions that the two protagonists go through to reach mutual respect and love. This was the first Gaskell novel that I have read, and her style, while more effusive and descriptive than Austen’s was a welcome surprise. Interlaced with this study of the diametric personalities are the differences in the lifestyles from agricultural southern England to the industrial north. Her characterizations were so detailed and real, that I cared deeply about the outcome of each of them.». Similarities are so evident, that Emily January considers that Gaskell is a Jane Austen’s plagiarist  in her blog, in a post titled «Elizabeth Gaskell: Jane Austen’s Plagiarist.»

First, we find two opposed characters: a strong woman, different of the rest of the women, intelligent and passionate; and a reserved, proud, and somehow tormented man. They belong to different social classes, and the man belongs to a higher class than the woman. They prejudge and dislike each other and we can find some disputes between them, where the female character stands out because of her brightness and her manners, not as polite as it is expected a girl to have. The man starts falling in love with her and he proposes marriage to her, but she rejects him, as she dislikes or hates the man «»I have every reason in the world to think ill of you. No motive can excuse the unjust and ungenerous part you acted there.» (Austen, Jane. p. 315). Proposal Mix-ups from Pride & Prejudice and North & South! However, throughout the story, the woman realizes he had prejudged and he is actually a great man, so she falls in love with him too. At the end of the novel, he asks her to marry him again and she accepts, so they get happily married. «‘Hush!’ said Margaret, ‘or I shall try and now show you your mother’s indignant tones as she says, «That woman!»‘» (Gaskell, Elizabeth. p. 436).

The difference between Pride and Prejudice and North and South is that Elizabeth and Mr Darcy’s marriage is more advantageous for Elizabeth than for Mr Darcy, as it says Patrick Parrinder in Nation and Novel: The English Novel from its Origins to the Present Day, «The culminating marriages in Austen’s fictions are socially and economically far more advantageous to the heroine than the hero.» whereas in North and South, since Margaret has inherited properties and a big amount of money, and Mr Thornton has impoverished, so is a more equal marriage.

In Jane Eyre it isn’t exactly like this because she is the governess of Mr Rochester’s mansion, so at the beginning, she depends financially on him. Besides, they don’t hate each other. But they belong to different social classes and their love and marriage does not seem possible. However, Jane’s behavior with Mr Rochester is quite unusual a little bit insolent since he was a rich man and she was her domestic helper. «‘I don’t think, sir, you have the right to command me, merely because you are older than I, or because you have seen more of the world than I have; your claim to superiority depends on the use you have made of your time and experience» (Brontë, Charlotte. p. 135). Mr Rochester was a mysterious and temperamental man, so we can find similar situations with Pride and Prejudice and North and South. Besides, although reasons are different, we can also find a first marriage proposal rejected, in the very last moment, and a second one accepted at the end of the story.

Another thing the novels have in common, is that, throughout the stories, Elizabeth, Margaret and Jane receive a third marriage proposal from other man, in Pride and Prejudice and Jane Eyre is a cousin, and they reject him.

As we can see, the three novels have similar love stories with more or less the same stages and at the end the characters get married, as it is expected, so the novels have a happy ending. The way these three characters face marriage has made them heroines of  the literature. But, at the same time, Austen, Gaskell and Brontë have been criticised because of the final marriage and happy ending.

We can learn more about these three authors in Penguin Classics On Air.

Add comment mayo 21st, 2013

02. Women in Pride and Prejudice, North and South and Jane Eyre

As in Austen’s Georgian Society, in the Victorian Society of Gaskell and Brontë  “Women were considered to be subordinate to men according to the laws of both God and Nature. Under the law, married women were unable to own property in their own name; they were not permitted to sue in their name or even to have legal rights to their own children. They were legally the property of their husbands, who could treat them as well or as poorly as they chose. A respectable woman was expected never to fall in love, but only to allow herself to grow to love the man she marries out of gratitude for his love of her.” (Teachman, Debra. p. 14)

But in the 19th century, Debra Teachman, in Understanding Jane Eyre : A Student Casebook to Issues, Sources & Historical Documents, says that, thanks to the revolutionary ideas of that time, there was some agitation for women’s rights (p. 11), and we can observe this change in Gaskell and Brontë’s main characters, Margaret Hale and Jane Eyre.

In Pride and Prejudice, published in 1813, the story takes place in the rural upper-middle class’ society, but, with Mr Darcy and Bingley’s family  we can see the differences between the high class. In my First paper, I explained this society. «The society within small towns and villages, where the majority of the population lived, was limited and limiting» (Jones, Hazel. p. 52). Women had boring lifes. They were not allowed to work, although, if the family was too poor, they were able to work as gorverness (Regulated Hatred: And Other Essays on Jane Austen. p. 27). «‘If I can but see one of my daughters happily settled at Netherfield,’ said Mrs. Bennet to her husband, ‘and all the others equally well married, I shall have nothing to wish for'» (Austen, Jane. p. 214). It was all about marrying to survive, as they were not economically independent, and having children, so women were educated in order to become good wifes and mothers. Hazel Jones explains in the first pages of Jane Austen and Marriage that Balls and social events were the most exciting thing in their lifes, and this was also related with marriage since it was there where men and women met each other and look for the perfect couple. Of course, there were rules and advices, that can be found in «conduct books», young men and ladies had to follow in those events, but these rules were not as strict as in the city.

This is the atmosphere where Jane Austen places Pride and Prejudice. Jane Austen does not include any historical problem or anything that can disturb that perfect atmosphere where the Elizabeth Bennet and Mr Darcy’s love story can develop as Jane Austen wanted.

Jane Eyre, published in 1847 , “is a bildungsroman, the story of the moral education of an individual. As a bildungsroman, it focuses on both the formal and the informal education of the main character, Jane Eyre, examining what she learns from the experience of life as well as the classroom as she comes of age.” (Teachman, Debra. p. 27)

Jane is an orphan girl. First, she lives with her aunt’s rich family in Gateshead. But she is treated as if she was less than a servant. «Don’t talk to me about her, John: I told you not to go near her: she is not worthy of notice. I do not choose that either you or your sisters should associate with her» (Brontë, Charlotte. p.29). When she is 10 years old, she goes to Lowood “a charity school for girls of lower genteel standing whose relatives do not have the means or the desire to care for them.” (Treachman,Debra. p. 3).  Here we can learn about the education of women in the 19th century and the harsh conditions of a charity school, where girls were malnourished and exposed to several illness. Debra Teachman says that «The intellectual rigor of Lowood, like that of most early nineteenthcentury schools for girls, is not strong.». As in Austen’s time, girls learnt more «suitable behaviour» than intellectual knowledges. Then, after finishing her education and spending two years being a teacher, she decides to leave Lowood and she starts working as governess in Thornfield. Here, we see again the high class society in the countryside, but from Jane’s point of view, instead of the point of view we have in Pride and Prejudice. Most of the story takes place in Thornfield, but, at the end, when Jane goes back with Mr Rochester, she moves to Ferndem, smaller than Thornfield. Debra Treachman explains that each location in Jane Eyre’s life, is a change in her life and in her personality. (p.2) In this novel we can also see women’s relation and dependence on men.  Throughout the novel, we can see different men in Jane Eyre’s life but all the time she depends on one of them. “Jane spends much of her life under the thumb of various men, all of whom, to differing extents, bully her.” (p. 10). Even Mr Rocherster, who loves her, is a bully sometimes because of men’s mentality in the 19th century (p.11).

North and South, published in 1855, shows different societies throughout the novel. At the beginning of the book, Margaret Hale is living in a high class family in London. «all the decisions she needed to make were what dress she would wear for dinner, and to help Edith to draw out the lists of who should take down whom in the dinner parties at home» (Gaskell, Elizabeth. p. 50). Then, she has returned to her parents’ house in a small village in the south of England’s countryside when her father decides to leave the rectory and leave Helstone. So she must leave the beautiful life in the countryside and move with her family to Milton, an industrial town in the north of England.  It is here, in Milton, where takes place the most part of the story. But, again, when her father dies, she is forced to leave Milton and go back to London and live with her cousin’s family. Elizabeth Gaskell offers us a quite wide vision of the society in the middle 19th century. “Gaskell has never had a wider range than in this novel: more characters than even before, drawn from all classes from just below the aristocracy downwards, of all shades of political and religious belief, experiencing all the conceivable likely crises of human existence, in London society, the rural south of England and the industrial North Midlands.” (Craik, W. A. Elizabeth Gaskell and the English Provincial Novel. p. 90). In Pride and Prejudice and Jane Eyre, we can not observe the historical context that surrounds the stories, but in North and South, although “Gaskell’s novels are more ‘about’ women than has been acknowledged.” (Stoneman, Patsy. Elizabeth Gaskell. p 2) Gaskell offers us a wide portray of England in the 19th century and historical aspects like the Industrial Revolution, play an important role in the novel. This novel show different women roles. We can see Margaret Hale a woman in a middle class family, but also Bessy and Mary, who work in a factory, or Margaret’s cousing and aunt, who belong to the London high society. «Female alliances occur naturally in the working-class, where needs are urgent and neighbours close by, but for Elizabeth Gaskell’s middle-class women, help comes less from friends than from servants. Like Mary Wollstonecraft, she believed that good sense and heroism were more likely where people were forced to confront real crises.» (Stoneman, Patsy. p. 31)

Pride and Prejudice, North and South, and Jane Eyre offer us different points of view of the 19th century England. We see different places, societies and classes, but they all have in common the inferiority of women and their economically dependence of man.

 

 

 

Add comment mayo 21st, 2013

01. Introduction

In my First Paper, I chose «Women in Pride and Prejudice» because when I first read Jane Austen’s novel, I thought that it was a realistic novel and it reflected women’s role in the 19th Century’s society. However, after rereading the novel and researching for my paper, I realized that, although it is true that Jane Austen describes her society and women’s roles, she is not really realistic. In fact, she is considered romantic by some scholars.

In Pride and Prejudice, she focuses on the characters’ psychology, especially women, and idealizes reality in order to develop the story she wants to tell us. So, she only describes the upper-middle class’ life in the rural society of the Georgian era.

Jane Austen is considered to be a forward-thinking woman, mainly because of her female characters and their personality and psychology and I wanted to know more about this topic. But, at the same time, I was interesed in having a more wide vision of the women’s roles in de different classes of the 19th century society.

For this reason, in my Second Paper, I have decided to compare Pride and Prejudice with Elizabeth Gaskell’s North and South and Charlotte Brontë’s famous novel, Jane Eyre.

These three books were written by famous female writers of the 19th Century in England, they have things in common, but they show different realities and social classes.

In this paper, we will see the differences and similarities between them, in order to have a better point of view of women’s roles in 19th society, but we will also know more about Jane Austen because of her influences or similarities with Gaskell and Brontë.

Add comment mayo 21st, 2013


Entradas recientes

Comentarios recientes

Archivos

Categorías

Meta